Rolling, Boxcar or Ice Pick? Acne Scar Types and the Best Fix for Each

November 8, 2026

This is a subtitle for your new post

Rolling, Boxcar or Ice Pick? Acne Scar Types and the Best Fix for Each

Quick answer: The three main acne scar types are ice pick scars (narrow, deep and V-shaped), boxcar scars (wider dents with sharp edges) and rolling scars (broad, wave-like dips with soft edges). Each responds to different tools: ice pick scars often need TCA CROSS or punch techniques, boxcar scars respond to resurfacing, punch methods or fillers, and rolling scars respond well to subcision and fillers. Most people have a mix and need a combined plan over several sessions.

What are the main acne scar types?

Acne scars form when deep inflammation damages the collagen in the skin. Most acne scars are atrophic, meaning the skin has lost tissue and sits lower than its surroundings. DermNet describes them as follows:

  • Ice pick scars: narrow, V-shaped scars that are deeper than they are wide, with sharp edges reaching the deep layers of the skin. DermNet reports they make up about 60 to 70% of atrophic scars.
  • Boxcar scars: wider round or oval depressions with distinct, steep edges. They can be shallow or deep.
  • Rolling scars: wide, shallow dips with sloping edges that give the skin a wavy look. They soften when the skin is stretched, because they are caused by fibrous bands tethering the skin from below.

Some people also get raised scars: hypertrophic scars, which stay within the original spot, and keloids, which grow beyond it. These are most common on the jawline, chest and upper back.

Why do acne scar types need different treatments?

The shape of a scar determines what will lift it. A treatment that resurfaces the top layer can soften shallow edges but does little for a deep, narrow ice pick. Filler can lift a rolling scar but may not fill a sharp-walled boxcar well. That is why dermatologists usually assess scar type before recommending a device or package.

DermNet notes that resurfacing may be best for more superficial scars, while deeper scars may need excision or other targeted methods.

What is the best fix for ice pick scars?

  • TCA CROSS: a high-strength trichloroacetic acid applied precisely into each scar to stimulate collagen and narrow it over a few sessions.
  • Punch excision: the scar is cut out with a small round tool and the skin is closed, leaving a finer line.
  • Punch grafting: for deeper scars, a small piece of skin replaces the removed scar.

Lasers alone often have limited effect on deep ice pick scars, though they can smooth the surrounding skin afterwards.

What is the best fix for boxcar scars?

  • Fractional laser: ablative or non-ablative resurfacing helps shallow boxcar scars by softening edges and building collagen.
  • Microneedling and RF microneedling: stimulate new collagen and are often combined with other methods. The AAD notes RF microneedling may work better than either technique alone.
  • Punch elevation or excision: for deeper boxcar scars with steep walls.
  • Fillers: can lift some scars and may stimulate collagen.

What is the best fix for rolling scars?

  • Subcision: a needle or cannula is passed under the scar to release the fibrous bands pulling the skin down. DermNet lists subcision for this purpose.
  • Fillers: restore lost volume and help keep the released skin lifted. The AAD notes filler results last from about 3 months to 2 years depending on the product, with touch-ups often needed.
  • Collagen-stimulating treatments: microneedling, RF microneedling and lasers to improve overall texture.

How do you build a plan for mixed acne scars?

Because most faces have more than one scar type, dermatologists often work in layers. A common sequence is to treat deep, narrow scars first with targeted methods such as TCA CROSS or punch techniques, release tethered rolling scars with subcision, and then use resurfacing or RF microneedling across the whole area to blend texture. Filler may be added where volume is still missing.

When you compare plans, it helps to ask:

  • Which scar types does the doctor see on my face, and where?
  • Which method is planned for each type?
  • How many sessions and how much downtime should I expect?
  • How will dark marks be prevented, especially in darker skin?

How long does acne scar treatment take, and what are the risks?

The AAD and DermNet both stress that active acne should be under control before scar treatment starts. Otherwise new scars keep forming.

Most scar plans take several sessions spread over months. Collagen remodeling continues for weeks after each session, so results build gradually. Scars usually improve rather than disappear completely, and DermNet notes acne scars are generally permanent, although they can become much less noticeable.

Possible risks include:

  • Redness, swelling and pinpoint bleeding for a few days
  • Post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, especially in darker skin
  • Bruising after subcision or filler
  • Rarely, infection, new scarring or filler complications

Tell your doctor about any acne medicines you have used in the past two years, including isotretinoin, since some can affect healing after procedures.

Frequently asked questions

Can I have more than one scar type?

Yes, most people have a mix of ice pick, boxcar and rolling scars. A good plan usually combines two or three methods.

Will one laser session remove my scars?

No. Resurfacing almost always needs multiple sessions, and deep scars may need other methods as well.

Are red or brown marks scars?

Flat red or brown marks are usually not true scars. They often fade over months and are treated differently from textured scars.

Can raised acne scars be flattened?

Raised scars and keloids may improve with steroid injections, silicone, laser or other treatments, though keloids can return. A combined approach is often used.

This article is for general information and does not replace a consultation with a doctor. Results and suitability vary from person to person.

Sources: DermNet: Acne scarring; American Academy of Dermatology: Acne scars diagnosis and treatment

Korean vs Imported Botox Brands: Does It Matter?
November 21, 2026
Korean and imported botulinum toxin brands all work the same basic way: they relax targeted muscles to soften wrinkles or slim the jaw. In the korean botox…
Botox vs Skin Botox: Muscles vs Pores
November 21, 2026
Regular Botox is injected into muscles to relax them and soften expression lines such as frown lines and crow's feet. Skin Botox, also called micro Botox…
Botox vs Filler: What Each One Actually Fixes
November 21, 2026
Botox (botulinum toxin) relaxes muscles to soften wrinkles caused by movement, such as frown lines, forehead lines and crow's feet. Fillers, most often…
Silhouette Soft vs Barbed PDO Threads
November 21, 2026
Silhouette Soft is a branded absorbable suspension thread that uses small cones to hold tissue, made from a poly-L-lactic acid-based material, while barbed…
Thread Lift vs HIFU: Which Lasts Longer?
November 21, 2026
A thread lift places absorbable threads under the skin to physically reposition tissue, while HIFU uses focused ultrasound to heat deep layers and trigger…
HIFU vs RF Lifting: What's the Difference?
November 20, 2026
HIFU (high-intensity focused ultrasound) focuses sound energy into small points at fixed depths, including the deep support layer under the skin, to lift…
Coolfase vs Thermage: Pain, Downtime and Results
November 20, 2026
Coolfase and Thermage FLX are both monopolar radiofrequency (RF) devices that heat the dermis to tighten skin and stimulate collagen. In the coolfase vs…
XERF vs Thermage FLX
November 20, 2026
XERF and Thermage FLX are both monopolar radiofrequency (RF) skin tightening devices that heat the dermis to firm the skin and stimulate new collagen. The…
Cool Soniq vs Ultherapy: Cooled vs Classic Ultrasound
November 20, 2026
Cool Soniq is a Korean high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) device made by Asterasys that cools the skin surface during treatment, while Ultherapy is…
ONDA vs InMode for a Double Chin
November 20, 2026
ONDA uses DEKA's Coolwaves microwave energy to heat fat and the skin above it, while "InMode" in Korean clinics usually means a combination of Forma…